Slate vs Tile Roofs
Slate vs Tile Roofs
Slate and tile can both be used as roof coverings, but the best choice depends on the existing roof, the proposed finish and the details around it. Use this guide to prepare better questions before replacement.
Updated
Choose for the roof you have, not only the finish you like
Slate and tile can create very different appearances, and there are choices within both categories. A photograph of a finish you like is a good starting point, but the existing roof and its details decide whether that choice is practical.
Start by explaining what matters to you: matching the surrounding roof, changing the appearance, reducing recurring repairs or planning a complete replacement. That gives the roofer a clearer brief than choosing a material name in isolation.
Ashurst & Sons works with full slate and tiled roofing. See the roof replacement service for the wider scope, or use the roof replacement cost guide to compare the parts of a proposal.
What to discuss before choosing
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Does the existing roof influence the choice? | The roof shape, details and current covering provide context for what can be proposed and how the finished roof will meet adjoining elements. |
| What appearance are you trying to achieve? | Colour, profile, size and layout affect the finished look. A sample or neighbouring roof can guide the conversation but cannot specify the whole job. |
| What happens at the edges? | Verges, ridges, valleys, walls and chimney junctions need compatible details. They should not disappear from the quote because the covering has been chosen. |
| What condition is underneath? | Preparation and removal can reveal information that is not visible from the ground. Ask how changes to the scope would be explained. |
| How will future repairs be approached? | Ask which parts of the roof may need attention later and whether the proposed finish makes access and replacement details clear. |
A covering quote is not a complete roof quote
One proposal may describe the material while another includes access, removal, edge details and clearing-up. A lower headline figure may simply leave more of the roof outside the stated scope.
Ask each roofer to identify the slopes and details included, what is assumed about the existing condition and which items are separate. If the material is still undecided, ask for the practical implications rather than comparing two names without context.
Do not rely on a generic claim about life expectancy, maintenance or suitability without checking the exact product and roof. Product information can vary, and the roof survey remains the starting point for an honest recommendation.
Bring your preference to a roof assessment
Send the postcode, property type, a safe ground-level photograph and the finish you are considering. Mention whether the roof is leaking, has been repaired before or is being replaced for appearance or condition.
Frequently asked questions
Is slate always better than tile?
There is no universal answer. The existing roof, the proposed product, appearance, weight, detailing and the condition of the roof all need to be considered together.
Can I choose a new roof covering from a sample?
A sample helps with appearance, but it does not establish whether the product suits the roof. The covering should be discussed alongside the roof shape, details and underlying condition.
Does changing from tile to slate mean the whole roof is different?
The covering is only one part of the work. Access, edges, junctions, roof details and any condition found during preparation still need to be included in the agreed scope.
Can Ashurst & Sons discuss slate and tiled roofing?
Yes. Slate and tiled roofing are part of Ashurst & Sons Roofing's approved roofing services. Send the postcode and safe photographs so the enquiry can be discussed in context.
Need a roof checked, repaired or replaced?
Call Ashurst & Sons Roofing to discuss the work, or send a safely taken photo by email. There is no call-out fee. The scope, price and workmanship guarantee are agreed for your job.
Fastest way to get a quote
07535840458Call and describe the job. If it is easier to show than explain, send a photo.
Ashurstroofing7@gmail.com- Hours
- Mon to Sat, 8am to 5pm
- Call-out fee
- None, quotes are free
- Guarantee
- 10 year workmanship guarantee
- Emergencies
- Emergency call-outs available